Both Members of the Club

By Robert Ecksel on November 7, 2013
Both Members of the Club
Teddy Atlas observed that "Both Members of the Club" asks, “What do we fight for?”

“Both Members of the Club,” Adam Berlin’s long awaited boxing novel, has just been released by Texas Review Press…

Both Members of the Club, Adam Berlin’s third novel, has just been released. Published by Texas Review Press and winner of the 2012 Clay Reynolds Novella Prize, Both Members of the Club, which shares a title with the iconic George Bellows’ painting of the same name, is his long awaited boxing novel.

Berlin is the most writerly of boxing journalists. In an age when anyone with an iPhone and a thought rattling around their head believes they are a writer, Berlin reminds us that writing is an art. It’s a serious endeavor meant to be taken seriously, and no place for ramblings disguised as prose, however facile but formless those ramblings may be.

To call Both Members of the Club a boxing novel is, however, something of a misnomer. Although one of the three main characters, Billy Carlyle, is a boxer on the downside of his career, the novel isn’t so much Billy’s story as the story of Billy and his two closest friends. One is an aspiring actor named Gabriel, our narrator. The other is a female artist named Sam. The three of them are in New York City, by circumstance rather than by design, but it’s where they’ve elected to pursue their fate; it’s also where fate has elected to pursue them.

New York is less a backdrop than a character in the book. Berlin, a longtime resident of the Big Apple, captures the pizzazz and paucity, the marvel and malfunction as only a gifted writer can. A third of the book takes place in Paris, which Berlin brings to life with his eloquent, Spartan style. But Both Members of the Club, while anchored by boxing, is less about Manhattan and Paris than about friendship and loyalty, hopes and aspirations, dreams and nightmares, with a sprinkling of delusion thrown in for good measure.

Berlin’s connection to boxing is profound. The fight scenes in Both Members of the Club, in particular, are rendered with such deftness that it feels less like reading a book than visiting the cinema. He understands that boxing is the ultimate proving ground for masculinity, with all that that means and does not. He also understands that outside the arena, with its screaming fans and testosterone fueled feats of derring-do, awaits the boulevard of broken dreams. But Berlin doesn’t overdo it. He is a master of restraint. His writing is more elegant than muscular; but however polished, it has an edge that suits both the material and the author himself.

Novels, like novelists, are a dying breed. The number of people who read books instead of tweets has never been smaller. While we may be experiencing the twilight of literacy, there will always be an audience for fine writing, an audience appreciative of the work that goes into creating something meaningful. They may be a minority. They may be dinosaurs in a world of butterflies. But storytelling, a seemingly lost art, remains central to the human condition, and can be found if one searches, can be found if one not only looks, but sees.

Teddy Atlas observed that Both Members of the Club asks, “What do we fight for?” That is true. But Both Members of the Club asks another question, and one with no easy answers: Which fight is next?

Follow us on Twitter@boxing_com to continue the discussion

Read More Blogs
Discuss this in our forums

Related Articles


This is a place to express and/or debate your boxing views. It is not a place to offend anyone. If we feel comments are offensive, the post will be deleted and continuing offenders will be blocked from the site. Please keep it clean and civil! We want to have fun. We want some salty language and good-natured exchanges. But let's keep our punches above the belt...
  1. Adam Berlin 05:48am, 11/11/2013

    Thank you for the heads-up, Matt.  My editor contacted the publisher so I hope Both Members of the Club is available in the UK soon.  All best, Adam

  2. Matt McGrain 08:48am, 11/10/2013

    Out of stock on the UK Amazon website!! Get on them, Adam.

  3. peter 06:14pm, 11/08/2013

    Boxing fans will enjoy this novel, even though it is not a typical boxing novel. Boxers are interesting people, and breathing within the pages of “Both Members of the Club” is Billy, a pro fighter who bleeds a lot.
    In Billy, Gabriel and Sam, the primary characters in “Both Members”, author Adam Berlin has given us three mysterious and haunting characters. All three are young, earnest adults embarked on their own private journey. They grab on to each other with friendship, holding each other up, they doggedly stumble forward. They seem to be in desperate pursuit of something beyond their reach. But something calls to each of them—perhaps this “something” is forever unattainable.

  4. Irish Frankie Crawford Beat Saijo aka Gimpel 07:29am, 11/08/2013

    I’m fossilized and very low tech but even I thought Kindle was the wave of the future for today’s writers including the writers on

  5. Ted 07:23am, 11/08/2013

    Nice review of a book written by a very nice man.

Leave a comment