Dempsey-Tunney 1927: The Long Count…

By Norman Marcus on March 1, 2012
Dempsey-Tunney 1927: The Long Count…
Gene Tunney said he could have gotten up anytime; he was just following the count.

It could have been a gangster movie from Warner Brothers. You just needed Bogart, Cagney, and Robinson…

“There’s nothing wrong with boxing that another Jack Dempsey couldn’t cure.”—Gene Tunney

Dempsey opened a restaurant in New York City’s Time Square. Jack Dempsey’s Broadway Restaurant opened in 1935 at 50th Street and 8th Avenue. It was a landmark for 38 years. Everyone knew Dempsey. It became standard procedure for the NYPD to hold up traffic so he could cross the street. Not just when he was champ but for the rest of his life. You could always find Jack, sitting in the back of his restaurant by a window. Always ready for a handshake, autograph, or just a “Hi Pal” for the customer.

This writer met Dempsey on a trip to New York City in 1960. I still remember that “bear” of a handshake.

One night Jack was closing up the restaurant at about 1:00 am. This was in the late ‘60s when Times Square was rundown and seedy. A druggie who didn’t follow boxing and never heard of the Manassa Mauler came up to Jack and demanded his wallet. The guy had a knife, and Dempsey got that old look in his eyes. He was in his mid-60s at the time. He hit the guy with a short right to the face. Dempsey was always the best short puncher in the business. The mugger hit the ground—out cold! Just then a police cruiser came around the corner, no siren, but lights flashing. When the boys in blue saw that it was Dempsey, they began to smile. The champ still had it! They took the punk to jail, charged with armed robbery. Dempsey and his wallet went home together.
Gene Tunney took a different path. He retired from boxing and married Polly Lauder of Connecticut, a member of the fabulously rich Carnegie family. He went to work on Wall Street and served on many corporate boards. Commuters would often see Tunney seated on the morning train going into New York. Most of them were unaware that the older man with the steel gray crew cut reading his newspaper was a real American hero. His son John Tunney Jr. later became a U.S. Senator from California.
Dempsey and Tunney, two real tough guys from the Roaring Twenties.

Why were these two men so famous? What had they done earlier in life that made each of them an American icon? It all began around 80 years ago.

It was September 23, 1926. William Harrison Dempsey, also known as Kid Blackie, Young Dempsey, and Jack Dempsey, had just lost the Heavyweight Championship of the World to Gene Tunney. Dempsey had come a long way since growing up in a Mormon home with 10 brothers and sisters. He had been a card shark, pimp, hobo, and accused draft dodger in his early years. He finally took the ring name Jack Dempsey. The first Jack Dempsey was a middleweight champion in the 1880s and an old favorite of the young fighter.

Gene Tunney, the man that beat him on that rainy night in Philly was his polar opposite. Dempsey’s nemesis was The Fighting Marine, a decorated war hero who had won the Light Heavyweight Championship of the AEF (American Expeditionary Force) in Paris in 1918. Tunney was a true gentleman who boxed scientifically and spent his free time reading Will Shakespeare and Walt Whitman. Never had two men been so different in character. Yet both fighters had the same goal, to be the best in the square ring. 
Dempsey faced Tunney that night way out of shape. Three years had passed since his wins against Tommy Gibbons in Shelby, Montana and Luis Angel Firpo at the Polo Grounds in Brooklyn, New York. Jack Dempsey was a shell of his former self. Too many years of easy living were part of the problem, while father time was the other part. A few sportswriters knew of Dempsey’s shocking condition. Some picked Tunney to win but they were laughed at. Jack was riding on his name and reputation that counted for a lot, but that would not help him when the bell rang for the first round.
Gene Tunney had been secretly practicing his straight right for three years. Ever since he saw France’s Georges Carpentier stagger the champ with the same punch in Jersey City in 1921. He wanted to get all his weight behind that haymaker. This straight right was his plan for victory.
In their first fight Tunney, as planned, threw the right but it missed the mark. It was supposed to hit Dempsey on the jaw like Carpentier’s punch, but landed high on his temple. It seemed to take some steam out of the champ. Dempsey was not the same fighter for the rest of the bout. Perhaps it was a concussion? Tunney won a 10-round decision. No knockout, just the judges counting up the rounds that each man won.

Jack’s wife, actress Estelle Taylor, was in shock. She asked him, “Ginsberg, look at your beautiful face! What happened to your nose?” Dempsey had just had a nose job for an upcoming movie role. Ginsberg was her pet name for Jack since he had a Jewish grandmother named Rachel Solomon. Estelle had a weird sense of humor. Dempsey just shook his head and said, “Honey, I forgot to duck.”

Dempsey wanted a rematch with the new champ and so did boxing fans all over the world. Boxing promoter Tex Rickard knew he had another million-dollar gate here, the fifth for Dempsey and himself.

Tunney on the other hand thought he had Dempsey’s number and was more than willing to meet him and put all doubts to rest. Tunney told the sportswriters, “I’d rather beat Dempsey than have all the money in the world.”

Tex Rickard didn’t share Tunney’s feelings. First, Rickard set up an elimination match with Jack Sharkey, also known as the Boston Gob, in Yankee Stadium on July 21, 1927. It would be another million-dollar gate for Jack and Tex. If he beat the new contender Sharkey, the rematch with Tunney was a go.

Sharkey came with his ‘A’ game the night he fought Dempsey. For six rounds Sharkey pounded Dempsey at will. In the seventh round Dempsey hit Sharkey a bit below the beltline. Sharkey went into his act. Wreathing in supposed pain, he turned to the referee to protest the blow. Sharkey forgot the most basic rule of boxing: “Defend yourself at all times.” While he had his profile turned toward Dempsey the former champ threw a right hook to his chin and the Boston Gob was sunk. It was a big payday for the Dempsey camp. When asked later by the press why he hit Sharkey with something of a cheap shot, Dempsey replied, “What did you want me to do, write him a letter?”

So the rematch with Tunney was set for Soldier Field in Chicago, September 22, 1927. This time Jack took Tunney more seriously. No booze, no smokes and no women. Women weaken the legs. Dempsey had a plan for the fight, at least his manager Doc Kearns did. Tunney, a great ring mechanic, was younger and faster than Jack. Dempsey needed practice and experience against this new type of fighter. So Kearns turned to Tommy Loughran, the Light Heavyweight champion at the time. Tommy was known as the Philly Phantom. His mantra was, “If they can’t hit me, they can’t hurt me.” Not only was Loughran fast like Tunney, but he had a strong right hand like him too. He would be Jack’s sparring partner. Tommy would box like Tunney for the next three months of training camp. (Ironically, Loughran later knocked out Jimmy Braddock to retain his Light Heavyweight title in 1929.)

The rematch, the Controversy of the Long Count, as with many overhyped fights, started as a repeat of the first. Both men were cautious as they circled each other for the first six rounds. It was a 20-foot ring that night which favored the faster Tunney. Dempsey was a knockout artist who liked something smaller, so his opponent couldn’t run on him. One hundred thousand people showed up to see this battle. There was a lot of money riding on this fight. Al Capone, who had bet a wad on Dempsey, reportedly offered to fix the fight for Jack but the ex-champ refused.

In the seventh round Dempsey decided to make his move. Tunney never saw it coming. Dempsey stepped in and landed a tremendous left hook right on the button. Bang! Tunney began to fall to the canvas as Dempsey continued to hit him with lefts and rights to the head.

As soon as Tunney hit the canvas, the timekeeper, Paul Beeler, started his stopwatch. Referee Dave Barry, however, was trying to get Dempsey away from Tunney and to a neutral corner. Barry was a saloon owner who was brought in at the last minute. Officials felt Capone may have gotten to the original referee Dave Miller. Barry was a veteran referee but was also hooked up with a rival Chicago mob! There was a new knockdown rule in effect and both fighters were aware of it. But Dempsey continued to hover over Tunney for 4.5 seconds before Barry could get him to that neutral corner. The referee then returned to start his count! Barry began counting “One, two,” and the timekeeper picked up Barry’s count, forgetting the 4.5 seconds already on his watch. Barry for some reason also slowed his count from five through nine until Tunney got up to continue the round. Was there different mob money on Tunney? Was the slow count insurance that Tunney would get up in a knockdown situation? Why was Miller replaced with Barry who had a shady background himself?

So the actual time on the canvas for Tunney was 17 seconds. The press however just added 4.5 seconds to the 9 seconds counted by Barry and came up with a 14-second count. So was it 14 seconds or 17 seconds that Tunney was down? It doesn’t really matter. Without the confusion of the new “neutral corner” rule, Tunney would have been counted out either way. Of course, Gene said he was awake and could have gotten up anytime; he was just following the count. But the way Tunney’s eyes rolled back into his head when Jack caught him with the left hook says otherwise. At the start of round eight Tunney dropped Dempsey with a right. Jack took a knee for a one count. Referee Barry immediately started the count over Dempsey without looking to see if Tunney was in a neutral corner! After that, the champ managed to stay away from Dempsey for the last two rounds. At the end of 10 rounds they went to the scorecards. Gene Tunney was again declared the winner by decision.

The Battle of the Long Count continues to this day. Was it just the fog of war or did some Chicago boys have a ringer there named Dave Barry, the same Dave Barry that was at war with rival boss Alphonse Capone of Cicero, Illinois? This Barry character certainly slowed down the pace of the count and Tunney was able to recover. Yet he was eager in round eight to hurry the count over Dempsey, unconcerned with Tunney’s whereabouts in the ring at that moment.

It could have been a gangster movie from Warner Brothers. You just needed Bogart, Cagney, and Robinson.  Of course Dempsey, who starred in many Hollywood films, would have to play himself. After all there was only one Jack Dempsey.

Follow us on Twitter@boxing_com to continue the discussion

Gene Tunney vs Jack Dempsey, II

Jack Dempsey -vs- Jack Sharkey 7/21/27 part 1

Jack Dempsey -vs- Jack Sharkey 7/21/27 part 2

Jack Dempsey -vs- Jack Sharkey 7/21/27 part 3

Discuss this in our forums

Related Articles


This is a place to express and/or debate your boxing views. It is not a place to offend anyone. If we feel comments are offensive, the post will be deleted and continuing offenders will be blocked from the site. Please keep it clean and civil! We want to have fun. We want some salty language and good-natured exchanges. But let's keep our punches above the belt...
  1. Brian Ivon Jones 07:36pm, 11/24/2013

    I remember meeting Gene Tunney in 1969 while I was working at a resort in the British Virgin Islands. Being a mad keen boxing enthusiast it was a wonderful experience being able to talk to Gene for the two weeks he stayed at the resort.
    He was an intelligent and witty gentleman with a fund of interesting stories.
    We did discuss the two Dempsey fights and one of his comments stuck in my mind. he said people always forget in the second fight Jack Dempsey was knocked down by Gene Tunney which was the hardest punch thrown in the fight.
    He did tell me a very funny story about Ernest Hemingway who fancied himself as a bar room brawler which i won’t recount as the author comes out of it rather badly but I seem to remember Gene’s finished the story by telling me he was forced to demonstrate to Ernest Hemingway the difference between an enthusiastic amateur and a very good professional.

  2. Michael Hegan 06:38pm, 05/19/2013

    ‘Fixing’ a fight was ...and never has been something Boxing has had to deal with.
    Bricks in the gloves were always whispered about when Dempsey damned near beat Jess Willard to death….

    IT was also whispered that it was supposed to happen in the first round…and Dempsey was supposed to ‘get outta Dodge’ ASAP…..

    ...instead..Willard had to take several more rounds of a horrific beating…before it had to be called.

    Jake LaMotta had some problems with this matter…and only cupla yrs back….‘Cheato’ got caught loading his gloves….

    so…...COMMISSION… licensed Boxer agrees
    hard ball medicals…as per Commission request
    random drug tests
    conduct requirement
    disability and pension options
    rigourous official training and screening

  3. Michael Hegan 06:21pm, 05/19/2013

    Iron Beach BUDDY….s’up ......
    we’re just getting rid of the snow…and dealing with the local flooding from annual run off…

    Had to get my girlfriend to haul up my window air conditioner unit from my basement….
    while she was down there….she turned on all my outside water outlets (gotta turn ‘em off for the winter…or you’ll explode all your water pipes due to freezing..)
    She’s six foot plus…and is a weight lifter…NOT A BODYBUILDER….but whatever she gets a hold of ...will generally move

  4. Michael Hegan 06:11pm, 05/19/2013

    from the footage available….I’d have to say Tunney beat the count…and could have gotten up earlier…had it been necessary.
    Tunney was a cool customer…and knew when to stay down…
    Dempsey ...had he not wanted to hump Tunney’s leg…..and should have gone to the neutral corner….may well have got his KO…..but he let his groin do his thinking…..

    Still…......One of the most memorable fights of all time…and will be for a century or so…..

  5. Michael Hegan 06:07pm, 05/19/2013

    you must give an artist his due…....Mr Marcus…..thank you for a great read….you educate the uninformed…and you bless the fans with a rich ....aged and polished red wine….

    Where I’m from… aged wine means somebody’s Mom put it in a bottle last winter….and most of the vinegar taste is gone…..and it is about 15% alcohol

  6. Michael Hegan 06:02pm, 05/19/2013

    crooked noses controlled the fight game in those days…..not like the fine upstanding, squeaky clean ...kind warm and compassionate promoters of today

  7. Eric Jorgensen 02:18pm, 05/16/2013

    I think it was Rex Lardner, who, in his book “The Legendary Championss,” remarked, “if Jack Dempsey was smoldering iron, Gene Tunney was cold, burnished steel,” which I always thought was very apt.

    Thanks for a great article, very well-written.

  8. Iron Beach 12:25pm, 03/03/2012

    Nice read. Dempsey was a badass and a legend.

  9. Don from Prov 12:11pm, 03/03/2012

    Mr. Thresher was a young man of forty at ringside that evening and saw it all.

  10. Don from Prov 12:10pm, 03/03/2012

    A different time—

    Different world really.

    And two very different fighters facing one another.  Very good article, Mr. Marcus.  Thanks, I really enjoyed it—

    BTW: I always heard two muggers/no knife.  And of the Sharkey fight—left hook low followed by left hook to the chin.  Stories morph from mouth to mouth. 

    Of course the Sharkey fight can be viewed, and I don’t know which is true.

  11. J. Mallow 09:01am, 03/02/2012

    The Irish and the Mormon fight. A long count.

  12. d. finch 08:07am, 03/02/2012

    I visited Dempsey’s home town and tiny house in Manassas, Colorado. What a story!

  13. mikecasey 07:20am, 03/02/2012

    Thanks, Jim. I never tire of stories about the great Jack!

  14. Jim Crue 05:35am, 03/02/2012

    one more Dempsey story.
    I have good friend who was a great white hope contender in the early-mid sixties. i have photos of him at Dempseys restaurant sitting and talking with Ray Arcel and other famous boxing guys of bygone era. My friend has told me that even into his sixties Dempsey was HARD as nail. He gave my friend a poke in the ribs which 50 years later he still painfully remembers. He was and is in awe of Dempsey.

  15. Jim Crue 05:00am, 03/02/2012

    For those of you interested in Dempsey and Tunney read The Dempsey bio by Roger Kahn ” A Flame of Pure Fire”. Kahn is a respected journalist and the book is well researched.
    I believe Dave Barry the referee was ‘fixed” as the author of this piece explains. I grew up in Chicago and my great uncle was at the fight, he was also like many a small time bootlegger, and he swore it was not on the level.
    For those interested in Tunney there was a bio written about him a few years ago that is also wonderfully researched and written. I have forgotten the author, I think his last name is Cavanaugh, but a search of the internet will tell you. The great trainer Ray Arcel toward the end of his life talked about Tunney’s alcoholism after his fighting days, which was a well kept secret especially in that generation. When I read the Tunney bio and read reviews of the book the only negative comments were about the fact that no bio has ever addressed his problem with alcohol.
    Thanks for a good article.

  16. mikecasey 02:25am, 03/02/2012

    First class article.

  17. Paul 01:29am, 03/02/2012

    I read Dempsey’s book/boxing manual recently. Really enjoy the frank, common-sense style of writing and old-timey phrases. Same as with the quotes in this article. Something much more mythical and impressive about these characters/events than will ever be left by this generation. Endless reels of Mayweather’s massive house on MTV Cribs…?

  18. Jack Lewis 10:16pm, 03/01/2012

    Great intro w dempsey / the picture painted was crisp and sharp!! Great read

  19. the thresher 05:49pm, 03/01/2012

    I was at ringside. It was a long count.