Pinoy Boxing: Villa, Yes. Manny Pacquiao, No. One?

By Michael Schmidt on December 4, 2012
Pinoy Boxing: Villa, Yes. Manny Pacquiao, No. One?
Flyweight Pacho Villa surely rates as the very best of a long list of great Filipino fighters.

Like those that followed, like Harry Greb, Tiger Flowers, Battling Siki, and Salvador Sanchez, Pancho Villa’s life ended much too abruptly…

June, 2012, Holiday Inn Lobby

A young man approaches with a Boxing Hall of Fame red ribbon ID attached to his shirt. “Hello, I am told you are Mike Schmidt and that you write for I just saw you talking to Mr. Steve Smoger and Donny Lalonde over there (across the lobby) and asked. I would like to show you a photo of my relative.” Out of the young man’s pocket, handled as if the most delicate of expensive jewelry, comes a wrinkled old black and white photo of a boxer, lean and sinewy, and looking much a great deal older than perhaps his actual years. Carlos “Cutman” Varela, standing beside me, exclaims “Wow, Schmeeet, Pancho Villa, one of the best of all time, eh?” The young man in response asks. “I am wondering if you might consider writing something about my relative.” What would one say other than yes under any circumstance and out of respect for what many consider as the greatest fighter to ever come out of the Philippines and certainly one of the best, if not the best, Flyweight Champions of all time.

With all due respect to Champion Pacquiao and the legendary “Flash” Elorde, this 5-foot-1-inch dynamo with the bowling ball shaped shoulders, Francisco Guilledo, aka “Pancho Villa,” described as a mix from Dempsey to Henry Armstrong, surely rates as the very best of a long list of great Filipino fighters.

At the time of his unfortunate death at the age of 23 Villa had amassed a record of 80-5-4. Various sources put his record at over 108 fights. Unlike many of those to follow after him, including Manny, young Villa was never stopped in his career. This was an astounding accomplishment when one considers the number of fights Villa had over such a short period of time. Old black and white footage of Villa, at the apex of his career, winning the Flyweight title over the legendary Jimmy Wilde (132-3-1 at the time) shows an in-and-out fighter with panther-like reflexes, indefatigable, as he uses a nonstop whirlwind attack of body shots and big left hooks, pounding the Champion into unconsciousness during the glory days of boxing with 40,000 spectators at the Polo Grounds in New York.

Villa, originally from the Negros, Occidental area, had already established himself as somewhat of a local phenom, wielding raw and natural talent and flattening bigger and older foes by the time he was contracted with sometime gold prospector, roustabout, carny man and boxing impresario Frank Churchill. Within two years of turning pro under Churchill’s guidance Villa would amass an incredible 55 fights often giving away upwards of 20 pounds against his opponents. By the time of his tragic death, Villa’s crowd pleasing style would be witnessed in fistic hot spots from Boston, New York, Baltimore to Detroit and San Francisco. Have fist, will travel!!!! 

Such was Villa’s talent that he was matched in his U.S. debut against tough Abe Attell Goldstein in Jersey City. Although the fight was ruled a non-decision, local scribes had Villa clearly winning a “newspaper decision.” Villa would shortly thereafter go on to win the “American Flyweight Championship.” In attendance ringside was the legendary writer Damon Runyon who proclaimed “It’s about time we had a flyweight good enough to give Jimmy Wilde a show. I think this Filipino is just the guy to do it.” In fact Villa was just the man.

Wilde, at age 31, while on the backside of a Hall of Fame career, was still a formidable force and reigning champion. On June 18, 1923, fans witnessed that type of raw unbridled attack that is forever remembered years gone forward in boxing discussions from bars to roundtables where Villa engraved his name into a Future Hall of Fame entry, moving in and out behind a solid jab, both hands piston pumping to the body and head, pounding a fellow Hall of Famer to be. The end easily could have come by corner stoppage in the sixth round, such was the beating. In the seventh round, Villa, again working down and up, body to head, landed a long large left hook followed by a compact chopping right hand. Wilde fell to the canvas, face first, as if shot. A new champion, never to lose his title in the ring, was crowned. Within two years after the Wilde fight, Villa would engage in another 25 fights; such were his physical attributes.

On July 4th, 1925, Villa was matched with another future Hall of Famer, Irish Jimmy McLarnin. Leading up to the fight Villa had suffered continuing pain due to a tooth infection. On the morning of the fight he had the tooth removed. Against medical advice Villa went through with the fight and by all accounts was not himself in terms of speed, power or stamina. Villa spent a great deal of the fight using his one hand to constantly protect one side of his jaw. Although he lost the fight he did not lose his title as McLarnin had come in over weight. Photos at the end of the fight show the young Filipino legend, with the broad shoulders turning to his corner as McLarnin and his fans, many in newsboy hats of the day, raising their fists in victory. It would be the last scene of Villa in the squared circle. Despite the dentist’s advice that he enter the hospital, Villa spent another week without further treatment. The infection, and further complication of blood poisoning, had spread to his throat, resulting in Ludwig’s angina, a connective tissue infection often related to dental infections. Villa was rushed into surgery but passed away the following day, 17 days short of his 24th birthday.

Ring Magazine voted Villa the 59th best fighter on a list of “80 best fighters of the last 80 years” in 2002. He was also voted as the number one flyweight, along with the magician that was, Miguel Canto, by the Associated Press. Like those that followed, like Harry Greb, Tiger Flowers, Battling Siki, and Salvador Sanchez, Villa’s life ended much too abruptly. One is left only to wonder what his overall career would have otherwise been. It is certain that Manny Pacquiao will not be voted the best welterweight of all time on a majority of anyone’s all-time list. That rank belongs to Sugar Ray Robinson by any person’s reasonable consideration. It is almost certain that the same could be said of Manny after careful consideration of other weight divisions. Villa, never knocked out, ranked as the very best in his weight, most certainly can be considered the best of a long list of great fighters from the Philippines. As the first ever Pinoy World Boxing Champion he of course holds special status

There are certain fighters—recently Brandon Rios comes to mind—by way of their raw unbridled love of gladiatorial-like battle that can be considered as fighters that would exist near or top of their class in any era. They are fighters by their style, a Molotov cocktail-like mix of natural unrivaled thought of mayhem, refined in the gym and by in-the-ring wars, honed to destructive skill that would hold their own against any. They are men’s men as the saying goes. Villa, the young man was that naturally gifted fighter, the number one fighter from the Philippines. Yes!!

Follow us on Twitter@boxing_com to continue the discussion

1922-09-14 Pancho Villa vs Johnny Buff

Pancho Villa vs Jimmy Wilde - 1923

Top10 Greatest Philippine Boxers of All Time

Glory Road - History of Philippine Boxing -

Discuss this in our forums

Related Articles


This is a place to express and/or debate your boxing views. It is not a place to offend anyone. If we feel comments are offensive, the post will be deleted and continuing offenders will be blocked from the site. Please keep it clean and civil! We want to have fun. We want some salty language and good-natured exchanges. But let's keep our punches above the belt...
  1. John Gilledo 12:11pm, 02/03/2015

    Good day let me introduce myself grandson of the greatest Filipino fighter Pancho Villa,as I recall during my visit to Ibhof in 2012 I had the pleasure of meeting mr Michael Schmidt briefly in the lobby of the hotel I was staying thank you for this informative and stamp of approval of Pancho Villa my grandfather the greatest #flyweight champion of the world.He will always hold a special place in the history of boxing.

  2. Mike Schmidt 04:52am, 12/06/2012

    Thanks Tex—much appreciated

  3. Tex Hassler 08:36pm, 12/05/2012

    Without question Villa was a truly great fighter in an era jammed full of tough competition. Villa learned his trade the best way to do it and that is by fighting often and staying in top shape. There are just not enough fighters today for one to learn like Villa learned boxing. Excellent well researched article, Amigo.

  4. Mike Schmidt 07:18pm, 12/05/2012

    “The Cutman” weighs in!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!”—Long time no see. Must be all of one week since you were working young Steve Wilcox corner—5-0 and lots more to go!!! Only you would immediately know who that photo was—take care Sir and see you shortly.

  5. Carlos Varela Jr. 06:59pm, 12/05/2012

    Warm and unforgettable article, best Flyweight of all times and without a doubt the best Filipino fighter of all time sorry Pacman is just the way it is.

  6. Mike Schmidt 08:05am, 12/05/2012

    Thanks M.C.—coming from you and The Bull is always the hightest form of scribe compliment

  7. Mike Casey 07:39am, 12/05/2012

    Great stuff, Schmidty - well written, my friend!

  8. Mike Schmidt 06:23am, 12/05/2012

    SIDE NOTE—Reprint article this week at Philboxing—article by Clarence George—DREAM FIGHT—DONAIRE VS VILLA—VILLA BY KNOCKOUT IN ROUND FIVE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  9. mike schmidt 05:00pm, 12/04/2012

    PS—and a shout out to our Fearless Editor and the boss of bosses above for another great Video selection. (Although I was hoping that you could fit those two Pinoy ladies kissing back into this article!!!!!)

  10. Mike Schmidt 04:59pm, 12/04/2012

    Maraming Salamat Ted. What can I say—when our fighter (at the time) Lisa “Bad News” Brown won the WBA Female Superbantam title from Pinoy Ana “The Hurricane” Julaton, broadcast from Canada overseas thru Philippine TV-GMS I had to learn at least a few Tagalog sayings mate!!!! Thanks much.

  11. the thresher 04:37pm, 12/04/2012

    Nice stuff, Michael. Enjoyable read.

Leave a comment