Pod Index: Malignaggi vs. Cano

By Boxing Analytics on October 25, 2012
Pod Index: Malignaggi vs. Cano
The Malignaggi vs. Pablo Cesar Cano split decision Saturday night drew a bit of controversy.

Tom Miller and Nelson Vasquez saw it 114-113 for Malignaggi, while Glenn Feldman inked a 119-109 tally for Cano. But the total scores are a bit misleading…

The Malignaggi vs. Cano split decision Saturday night drew a bit of controversy. Here we do not take a normative position, but rather, we examine the round by round scoring for consistency. Judges Tom Miller and Nelson Vasquez saw it 114-113 for Malignaggi, while judge Glenn Feldman inked a 119-109 tally for the challenger Cano. But the total scores of this very competitive fight are a bit misleading. At face value, the total scores indicate that judges Miller and Vasquez saw the fight exactly the same, while judge Feldman was off-base. However, when we calculate the Pod Index for round by round consistency, we see a somewhat different picture. The judges were actually in agreement in five of the 12 rounds. In the seven split rounds, Glenn Feldman was in the minority five times, while Tom Miller dissented twice. Impressively, Nelson Vazquez was a part of the majority or unanimous opinion in all 12 rounds. The total Pod Index for the match was 61.1%—8 percentage points below the 69.6% overall average for fights falling in the most competitive category.

These three judges are all veterans with strong track records of consistency in championship fights over the past four years. Below is snapshot of their overall Pod Index scores, along with the average score of all judges. The numbers indicate that Malignaggi-Cano was most likely one of those fights where each judge’s style preference and vantage point had a noticeable influence on the results. My conclusion: three quality judges, who typically score fights consistently with their counterparts, had a legitimate difference of opinion on Saturday night.

Follow us on Twitter@boxing_com to continue the discussion

Showtime Boxing - Recap: Danny Garcia vs. Erik Morales II - Brooklyn Boxing, Quillin, N'Dam, Cano, Malignaggi



Discuss this in our forums

Related Articles

Comments

This is a place to express and/or debate your boxing views. It is not a place to offend anyone. If we feel comments are offensive, the post will be deleted and continuing offenders will be blocked from the site. Please keep it clean and civil! We want to have fun. We want some salty language and good-natured exchanges. But let's keep our punches above the belt...
  1. the thresher 09:58am, 10/25/2012

    I had it a draw with an arrow pointing towards Cano. No way did Paulie win that one fighting in the pocket the way he did and letting Cano control matters, especially to the body.

  2. Boxing Analytics 08:12am, 10/25/2012

    Ted, how did you score the fight?

  3. the thresher 05:18am, 10/25/2012

    Great stuff!! Keep it coming.

Leave a comment