Williams Decisions Lara/Judges Punish Boxing

By Robert Ecksel on July 10, 2011
Williams Decisions Lara/Judges Punish Boxing
Paul Williams may be the money fighter, but he’s not the better fighter (Emily Harney)

We can observe the sport of boxing on TV or at the fights, but the business of boxing happens in places about which most of are neither aware nor ever frequent…

Boxing is an intriguing, thrilling, melancholy sport. But we should never forget that boxing is also a business. We observe the sport of boxing on TV or at the fights, but the business of boxing happens in places about which most of are neither aware nor ever frequent.

So, on one hand there’s the public face of boxing, the public face of pride and scar tissue, resilience and broken noses, where courage is not measured with teaspoons, but with fistfuls of glory. And on the other there’s the private face of boxing, the face that is tanned and well-fed, always smiling and reassuring, but never telling it like it really is.

After his devastating KO loss to Sergio Martinez last November, Paul “The Punisher” Williams (40-2, 27 KOs) hoped to make a statement Saturday night at Boardwalk Hall in Atlantic City. He wanted everyone to know that he was back, that he was better than ever, and that the knockout he suffered at Martinez’s hands was a fluke, a bump in the road on his road to greatness.

Unfortunately for Williams, his opponent Erislandy Lara (15-1-1, 10 KOs) had a statement of his own to make, and he wasn’t about to let The Punisher prevent him from making it.

Lara, like all of us who follow the fights, had theories about Williams’ chin going in. But unlike the rest of us, Lara was positioned to put those theories to the test. With pinpoint accuracy he dominated the first three rounds, using his power, ring smarts and resourcefulness to keep Williams on the defensive.

Williams started to open up in rounds four, five, and six. He was the busier fighter, finally letting his hands go and landing some punches, while Lara continued sharpshooting.

The Punisher began taking some serious punishment in the seventh and eighth rounds. Williams was tiring, his hands were low, and Lara’s hard lefts were now being thrown in combinations with hard rights. Williams’ offense, such as it was, was simply no match for Lara’s performance. It was though he had Williams’ chin in his sites and all he had to do was pull the trigger.

Williams rallied at the beginning of round nine, but his rally was short-lived as Lara picked up the action, landing straight lefts with almost no resistance from his opponent. Williams’ head was swiveling this way and that, and every other punch Lara landed buckled his knees.

What little defense Williams displayed in the first ten stanzas had all but disappeared during the championship rounds. Lara continued to land at will. He tied up Williams when he tried to get off, and continued punishing The Punisher. Williams was bleeding from the nose and mouth. It was getting ugly, as it always gets ugly when one man loses badly. Those watching the fight with me were yelling at the TV, “Stop it! Stop it! What’s the point?” There was no point; that was the point. The announcers were writing Williams’ epitaph with sound over the airwaves. Williams was a beaten fighter, who was going to get beaten some more.

To those not blind, deaf and dumb (or worse) to the goings-on in the ring, Lara owned Williams. The Cuban beat him to the punch all night long, landing long looping lefts to Williams’ face whenever he wanted. The one-dimensional Williams didn’t have an answer to the beating he was taking.Paul Williams fought the way he always fights—the only way he knows how to fight—hanging tough, but it wasn’t enough.

Williams came into the fight without a blueprint, and his sleepy-eyed trainer should be put to pasture for dereliction of duty. But Williams never stopped fighting. He fought his inside game as well as he ever has, a big man fighting like a small man. It was just that the shorter (by four inches) Lara had Williams’ number and left the former welterweight champion a bruised and bloodied husk after twelve rounds.

Any impartial observer watching the fight knew that it was, if not a shutout by Lara, a lopsided decision in the Cuban’s favor. Yet the judges scored the bout 114-114, 115-114, 116-114, a majority decision for Williams.

Boxing is the most subjective of sports. Even though we have judges and referees, rules and standards for evaluating a boxer’s performance, we also rely on our gut to tell us who has more work to do, and who—if it’s a decision—actually won.

Saturday night, that man was Erislandy Lara. Williams may be the money fighter, but he’s not the better fighter, not by far.

Follow us on Twitter@boxing_com to continue the discussion

Paul Williams vs Erislandy Lara - Part 1 - Watch full fight



Paul Williams vs Erislandy Lara - Part 2 - Watch full fight



Paul Williams vs Erislandy Lara - Part 3 - Watch full fight



Paul Williams vs Erislandy Lara - Part 4 - Watch full fight



Paul Williams vs Erislandy Lara - Part 5 - Watch full fight



Paul Williams vs Erislandy Lara - Part 6 - Watch full fight



Paul Williams vs Erislandy Lara - Part 7 - Watch full fight



Juan Manuel Marquez v. Likar Ramos, Judges Suspended in Williams-Lara



Discuss this in our forums

Related Articles

Comments

This is a place to express and/or debate your boxing views. It is not a place to offend anyone. If we feel comments are offensive, the post will be deleted and continuing offenders will be blocked from the site. Please keep it clean and civil! We want to have fun. We want some salty language and good-natured exchanges. But let's keep our punches above the belt...
  1. The Thresher 05:24am, 07/17/2011

    troothsayer, Uh huh, but all I am saying is that the three blind mice at least had a hook to hang from.

  2. troothsayer 11:33pm, 07/16/2011

    @The Thresher: PW got his ass handed to him, plain and simple!
    We bombarded the coast of Normandy on D-day, and the Germans were still able to cut our troops to ribbons on that beachfront!
    Sheer numbers won the day!
    PW on the other hand, was a humbled, beaten man, at the end of that fight!
    He knew he lost it, and no one in the arena was more shocked that was PW after that lie of a decision was read!

  3. The Thresher 05:28pm, 07/16/2011

    Good link. Thanks.

  4. Dock 03:39pm, 07/16/2011

    Sometimes, the Commission is the problem, as much as the judging.
    http://womenboxing.com/NEWS2005/news121205rameyobrian.htm

  5. The Thresher 09:52am, 07/16/2011

    One thing everyone seems to miss is that PW threw over 1,000 punches and I believe landed more than Lara. Thus, an argument could be made (however weak) that the judges did have a perspective. Just saying. Too many of these writers are running wild with this when they forget the Toney-Tiberi affair—or Casamayor-Santa Cruz. Let’s have soome historical perspective is all I am saying. I am not criticizing you. I just have a hard time with sanctimonious rage when it is too myopic. Peace.

  6. Robert Ecksel 03:26pm, 07/15/2011

    You have a point, Thresher. I hear you. But we can’t assume a thorough investigation was done in four days, any more than we can assume that there was or was not corruption in the case of the three judges. Boxing is the Outlaw Corridor and has been forever. People are still arguing if Jack Johnson went in the soup against Jess Willard a century ago. I guess the more things change the more they stay the same.

  7. The Thresher 02:52pm, 07/15/2011

    Writing and/or speaking with authority doesn’t necessarily make something true.” Of course not, but in the absence of hard proof of corruption, my assumption is that there was none. It’s the best I can do. You want an investigation, you have to go back to Tiberi-Toney—which also was in AC.

  8. Robert Ecksel 02:59pm, 07/14/2011

    We know how to judge incompetence. All we need to do is trust our lying eyes. But how do we judge corruption? By asking those who have been accused if they’re corrupt? Good luck with a getting a straight answer to that. Or by launching an investigation that’s completed in less than a week? How thorough might that be? I don’t know how anyone can be certain of anything. Writing and/or speaking with authority doesn’t necessarily make something true.

  9. The Thresher 01:46pm, 07/14/2011

    Too much is being made of this. The judges were incompetent, but not corrupt. Therefore, the judges can be suspended, but the outcome must stand. Let’s move on.

  10. Joe 04:12am, 07/11/2011

    Big George told us that you can never leave it up to the judges and quite frankly it was a close fight. Lara should have simply knocked The Punisher out. And (choose a higher power) knows that he connected with that overhand left AT LEAST 25 times cleanly and couldn’t knock him out. I could have knocked him out if I hit him that cleanly that many times. The Punisher MUST fix that defensive flaw or it’s going to be even uglier than the Sergio KO next time out.

  11. bergmuff 12:24pm, 07/10/2011

    this majority robbery only happens because nobody stands up against it. boxing scribes who suddenly don’t remember the names of these corrupt judges are just as guilty ot the travesty. judges should be held accountable for the robbery just as bank robbers, and thieves. they should be banned from boxing just as boxers who are caught cheating.

Leave a comment